Prayer, Ritual, Magick February 25, 2008
Posted by Ian in Ancient Greek, Community, Crowley, Divination, Ethics, Modern Polytheism, Open Theology, Protagoras, Religion and Faith.trackback
The notion of magick in the Crowley-esque sense of the term tends to haunt modern polytheism. Magick seems to run counter to the devotional elements we tend to see as properly religious. Praising the divine seems to be one thing, plying the divine for favors quite another. In general, both are seen as acceptable, but their relationship is a little obscure.
Crowley’s phrasing exacerbates the problem by making magick primarily a question of Will, of training the Will to exert itself over the world. There are all sorts of qualifications here, since that isn’t the Will in the sense of ego, but Will in the sense of higher self. And training the Will isn’t simply a matter of getting what you want but of moving in harmony with the higher Will so that you want what is proper to it.
Still, this seems a bit different than the attitude that directs itself toward a divine presence outside of and beyond itself. The importance of banishing, for example, points toward a defensive posture toward the world of spirit. In more devotional frames, we tend to think that too much asking is a bit gauche.
To paraphrase a friend, we have the sense that the gods have better things to do than just help us with some money. What encounter we do have with the divine through devotional work tends to be received as an injunction rather than as a pact we must examine before accepting.
This pans out at the level of ritual, too, with there being two sorts of ritual, the sort meant to manipulate and the sort meant to praise. The problem isn’t unique to paganism and we can see variations of it Christian, Islamic, Judaic, Hindu, Buddhist, and other traditions. The question of self-worth gets posed pointedly in these discussions. How important am I in relation to the divine?
I don’t work well in that magickal mindset and I suspect I’m not alone in that. It jars with my basic reason for pursuing spirituality. Yet I feel like not praying for things is equally problematic, especially since so much of my practice has to do with the sacredness of the world, not just localized in divinities ‘out there’ but in the world ‘right here.’
The approach I take is that praying for something is more than asking for some thing in your life. It’s asking for the divine to enter into your life through that thing you pray for and giving your promise that you will nurture that spark of the divine as it enters that place. The prayer does not end with the request or the granting of the request, but continues as we put that blessing to use.
We ought, whenever possible, to use that blessing to deepen our connection with the divinity granting it. In so doing, we bring that part of the world into closer harmony with that sacred divinity.
I don’t think that’s solely an intellectual distinction, either. In making requests in this way, it shifts the way in which we relate to the divine and very possibly changes how the divine responds to us. It makes the self a point in the circulation of blessings rather than the endpoint of them.
My joy, my happiness, becomes an opportunity for shared joy. I may manage and care for them for myself, because my self is the point of entry for them, but my self is not the measure of them.
Unlike Protagoras, I do not think man is the measure of all things. I define my religiosity in great part by the notion that there are standards by which man is judged that man does not create. The effort to reduce religion to man, to the symbols we create, to the movements of our psyche alone, undoes the movement of devotion so central to it.
This isn’t to do away with reflecting about who we pray to and for what. But it becomes less a manner of caution (don’t make a bad deal, get cheated) than of care (what blessings can you make the most of).
Uck, I love this article.
At least in Feri, this question of Will is, as you hinted at above, linked to the question of aligning your will with the divine. This ‘higher will’ is what we refer to as “the work of this god,” the work or Will of our Godself. (Interestingly, some branches of Feri call the Godsoul “Ori.”) Soo, I think that in this sense aligning and sharpening your will is a crucial part of devotional work. Finding your self both human and divine, finding your work, and also realizing that it’s okay to do magick for mundane things that help you *enjoy this blessed, embodied existence.
At the same time, I get what you’re saying about ‘asking for things.’ And I think you hit the nail on the head about “[using] that blessing to deepen our connection with the divinity granting it.” On a really simple level, cultivating gratitude and an awareness of where yr blessings are coming from is a part of that work.
I think we’re pretty much on the same page about this. My biggest thing is just that the Will/Godself/Ori/etc. isn’t usually identical with the daily sense of self we walk around with, so there are a lot of ways in which aligning ourselves with our Will/Godself/Ori is very much akin to aligning ourselves with the divine in the form of Freya/Star Goddess/Yemaya.
We begin by shifting our attention away from what we want (little self, ego) toward the ways we can invite the intervention of our higher Self and nurture them. I think so long as we aren’t entirely off-center spiritually, most of those things are actually going to match up with things our little self wants, although perhaps in a slightly different form. It’s, as you say, a shift in how we appreciate them.
Yes. In fact, so much of my work these days has been leading me to crash up against the limitations of my little ego self (what Jay Michaelson calls “yetzer hara,” in an interesting interpretation of the term– “evil inclination” as the small-mindedness that takes the ego/Talker/personality as the self) in an attempt to be in better alignment. I wish you’d posted this article in yr livejournal so I could put it in my “memories” section!